Lincoln
Everything I have heard about Lincoln thus far has been overwhelmingly positive. People are calling it the best movie of the year, and a masterpiece. While I liked the film, I wouldn't go that far. For the most part, for me, Lincoln is merely an acting showcase for some of the best performances of the year.
Steven Spielberg's Lincoln follows about a month in his life after he's been reelected for his second term and when he's trying to get the 13th amendment (abolishing slavery) passed through the House of Representatives. What follows is a beautifully acted, well directed movie in which every character actor you can think of talks and talks and talks and talks and talks and talks (and then talks some more!) for two and a half hours. These characters give speeches and tell anecdotes and three scenes later someone very long windedly reiterates exactly what a different character has said already. But the glacial pace and ridiculously long dialogue scenes weren't even my biggest problem with the film. My biggest problem was this: when you think about Abraham Lincoln, arguably the greatest president in history, what are two things you think about immediately. Your answer will most likely include The Gettysburg Address and his assissination. This movie shows you neither. You can argue that the movie focuses on that month long period, and that's fine. But the movie does give you the Address and his death (in a way) without showing either, and I think that's a cop out. Like my boyfriend said, it would be like watching a three hour movie about the Titanic and then having it end with some old white guy saying, "Oh, well, the ship sank." After we already sat through a movie with no action to speak of, at least give us something!
Spielberg is considered the greatest living filmmaker, but he's never been one of my favorites. I will say that I unabashadly love two of his films - Jaws and Schindler's List. There are moments of greatness in this film, like many of his other films. Two particular scenes that come to mind, are a beautifully shot Lincoln standing in front of a window while talking to his wife, and Lincoln's son Robert (Joseph Gordon-Levitt, all but wasted in a small and fruitless role) following a wheel barrow of body parts near the end. Both of those scenes stand out as being closer to art than movie making. But, for the most part, this is a long-winded and flawed historical epic (which means it will win all kinds of Oscars).
The saving grace here are the performances. Daniel Day-Lewis, who is the greatest living actor, becomes Abraham Lincoln to the point where it is a little scary. It's uncanny how much he looks like the great man, especially in profile. I think he's well on his way to winning a third Oscar because his performance is that good and natural. I had no problem beliving that this was actually President Lincoln. And the great thing about this performance is how different it is from his last Oscar winning role in There Will Be Blood. That performance was loud and bombastic and showy. His Lincoln is refined and subtle, a beautifully powerful performance. It's hard to think of any actor stealing the show from Day-Lewis, but co-star Tommy Lee Jones very nearly does. One can argue that this is just another wise cracking version of every character he's ever played before. But, I disagree. He is responsible for the single greatest scene in the movie and if that scene in his office near the end isn't his Oscar nominee clip, then I don't know what to say. The final member of the trifecta is Sally Field. All I know about Mary Todd Lincoln is that she was supposedly crazy, but Field makes her so much more complicated. Instead of a crazy lady, she's a woman grieving for a lost son and trying to live with a man who is beloved by everyone.
The most fun part of Lincoln, however, is playing Spot the Character Actor. Between this movie and Argo, I think every character actor working in Hollywood had a job for at least a few weeks. In Lincoln, the great supporting cast includes David Strathairn, James Spader, Hal Holbrook, John Hawkes, Jackie Earle Haley, Bruce McGill, Tim Blake Nelson, Lee Pace, Jared Harris, Lukas Haas, Dane DeHaan and more.
So, while Lincoln is being hailed as a masterpiece, I tend to disagree. It's a good movie, that's for sure, and the three main performances are so stellar that they definitely deserve Oscar nominations (to say the least). However, Lincoln, for me, didn't live up to the hype.
Grade: B-
Labels: Daniel Day-Lewis, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Tommy Lee Jones